Scientists solve mystery of blinking brown dwarfs

Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech

In 5 seconds

In a study in Science, UdeM astrophysicist Étienne Artigau and an international team of researchers reveal that giant waves cause large-scale movement of particles.

Dim objects called brown dwarfs, less massive than the Sun but more massive than Jupiter, have powerful winds and clouds – specifically, hot patchy clouds made of iron droplets and silicate dust. Scientists recently realized these giant clouds can move and thicken or thin surprisingly rapidly, in less than an Earth day, but did not understand why.
 
Now, researchers including Université de Montréal astrophysicist Étienne Artigau have a new model for explaining how clouds move and change shape in brown dwarfs, using insights from NASA's Spitzer Space Telescope. Giant waves cause large-scale movement of particles in brown dwarfs' atmospheres, change the thickness of the silicate clouds, the researchers report in the journal Science.


With Artigau and McGill University astrophysicist Nicolas Cowan, both members of the Center for Research in Astrophysics of Quebec and the Institute for Research on Exoplanets, the international team of researchers include was led by the study's principal author, Daniel Apai, associate professor of astronomy and planetary sciences at the University of Arizona in Tucson.

The study also suggests these clouds are organized in bands confined to different latitudes, traveling with different speeds in different bands.
 

Like Jupiter's belts and zones

The distribution and motions of the clouds on brown dwarfs in this study are similar to those seen on Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune. Neptune has cloud structures that follow banded paths, too, but its clouds are made of ice. Observations of Neptune from NASA's Kepler spacecraft, operating in its K2 mission, were important in this comparison between the planet and brown dwarfs.
 
"The atmospheric winds of brown dwarfs seem to be more like Jupiter’s familiar regular pattern of belts and zones than the chaotic atmospheric boiling seen on the sun and many other stars," said study co-author Mark Marley, of NASA's Ames Research Center in California's Silicon Valley.
 
Brown dwarfs can be thought of as failed stars because they are too small to fuse chemical elements in their cores. They can also be thought of as "super planets" because they are more massive than Jupiter, yet have roughly the same diameter. Like gas giant planets, brown dwarfs are mostly made of hydrogen and helium, but they are often found apart from any planetary systems. In a 2014 study using Spitzer, scientists found that brown dwarfs commonly have atmospheric storms.

More than a year of observation

Due to their similarity to giant exoplanets, brown dwarfs are windows into planetary systems beyond our own. It is easier to study brown dwarfs than planets because they often do not have a bright host star that obscures them.
 
"It is likely the banded structure and large atmospheric waves we found in brown dwarfs will also be common in giant exoplanets," Apai said.
 
Using Spitzer, scientists monitored brightness changes in six brown dwarfs over more than a year, observing each of them rotate 32 times. As a brown dwarf rotates, its clouds move in and out of the hemisphere seen by the telescope, causing changes in the brightness of the brown dwarf, a phenomenon that has been observed for the first time by Artigau and his collaborators in 2009. Scientists then analyzed these brightness variations to explore how silicate clouds are distributed in the brown dwarfs, a field in which Professor Cowan is an expert.
 
Researchers had been expecting these brown dwarfs to have elliptical storms resembling Jupiter's Great Red Spot, caused by high pressure zones. The Great Red Spot has been present in Jupiter for hundreds of years and changes very slowly: Such "spots" could not explain the rapid changes in brightness that scientists saw while observing these brown dwarfs. The brightness levels of the brown dwarfs varied markedly just over the course of an Earth day.

Large waves make cloud structures rotate

To make sense of the ups and downs of brightness, scientists had to rethink their assumptions about what was going on in the brown dwarf atmospheres. The best model to explain the variations involves large waves, propagating through the atmosphere with different periods. These waves would make the cloud structures rotate with different speeds in different bands.
 
University of Arizona researcher Theodora Karalidi used a supercomputer and a new computer algorithm to create maps of how clouds travel on these brown dwarfs.
 
"When the peaks of the two waves are offset, over the course of the day there are two points of maximum brightness," Karalidi said. "When the waves are in sync, you get one large peak, making the brown dwarf twice as bright as with a single wave."
 
The results explain the puzzling behavior and brightness changes that researchers previously saw. The next step is to try to better understand what causes the waves that drive cloud behavior. 

About this study

“Zones, Spots, and Planetary-Scale Waves Beating in Brown Dwarf Atmospheres,” was published Aug. 18, 2017 in Science. In addition to Daniel Apai, Theodora Karalidi (University of Arizona), Mark Marley (NASA Ames), Étienne Artigau (Université de Montréal, iREx) and Nicolas Cowan (McGill University, iREx), the team includes Hao Yang (University of Arizona), Davin Flateau (University of Arizona, University of Cincinnati), Stanimir Metchev (University of Western Ontario, Stony Brook University), Esther Buenzli (ETH Zürich), Adam Burgasser (University of California, San Diego), Jacqueline Radigan (Utah Valley University), and Patrick Lowrance (Caltech).

About the Jet Propulsion Laboratory

JPL manages the Spitzer Space Telescope mission for NASA's Science Mission Directorate, Washington. Science operations are conducted at the Spitzer Science Center at Caltech in Pasadena, California. Spacecraft operations are based at Lockheed Martin Space Systems Company, Littleton, Colorado. Data are archived at the Infrared Science Archive housed at the Infrared Processing and Analysis Center at Caltech. Caltech manages JPL for NASA. For more information about Spitzer, visit: http://spitzer.caltech.edu or http://www.nasa.gov/spitzer.

Media contact

  • Marie-Ève Naud
    Institut de recherche sur les exoplanètes de l'UdeM
    Tel: 514-343-6111, poste 7077