Mental health and peer support: sometimes online communities can help

In 5 seconds While social media often take heat for their negative effects on mental health, a recent study of Facebook and Reddit support groups reveals a positive side.
A man is checking his smartphone.

The mental health impact of social media—particularly online peer support groups—is unclear.

“The scientific literature is contradictory,” said Université de Montréal psychology professor Diana Cárdenas. “Some studies have found benefits, while others have concluded that these spaces are harmful to people with mental health issues.”

To dig deeper, Adriana Ugolini Benatti de Siqueira, a master’s student supervised by Cárdenas, explored this question in her thesis. Her findings were recently published in BMC Psychology.

(copie 3)

A quasi-experimental approach

“One factor previous studies haven’t examined is whether people feel a sense of belonging to their support group,” noted Cárdenas. Could this have a bearing on the group’s impact?

Most of the previous work used correlational or qualitative methods. Siqueira instead adopted a quasi-experimental approach to test whether identification with a support group could be the psychological mechanism behind the beneficial effects experienced by some members.

She recruited 297 participants; 193 were members of mental-health support groups on Facebook and Reddit, and 104 belonged to other types of groups. Half of the peer support group members completed a task designed to reinforce their identification with the group, while the other half performed a task that focused their attention on their personal identity. The members of non-mental-health groups all completed the group identity reinforcement task. 

All participants then answered an online questionnaire measuring their group identification, self-efficacy (confidence in their ability to cope with mental health and life challenges), level of participation in the group, level of well-being and endorsement of mental illness-related stereotypes.

(copie 4)

The group effect

Among the mental-health support group members, those who completed the group identity reinforcement task reported stronger group identification, higher self-efficacy and a greater sense of well-being. Paradoxically, those who identified strongly with their peer support group had more prejudiced views about other people living with the same challenges.

The results suggest that belonging to a group isn’t enough. It is the importance attached to the group that unlocks positive effects on behaviours and attitudes.

Strong group identification not only made members feel more capable of managing symptoms but also enriched other areas of their lives. “These participants felt more engaged and reported a greater sense of meaning in their lives,” said Siqueira. 

The benefits of group identification weren’t limited to mental-health groups. Members of hobby or sport communities also reaped rewards.

Breaking down barriers

For people with mental-health struggles—who may already find social interaction difficult—the emotional and psychological bond with an online community can be especially valuable. Since online support groups have no geographic or financial barriers, they are available outside the hours of health-care services, in the comfort and safety of one's home.

For better or worse, social media are here to stay, and health-care professionals need to take them into account, said Cárdenas. The question is: “How can we maximize the benefits and minimize the harms?” she added.

With more people turning to AI chatbots for emotional support, online groups take on even greater importance, she concluded. “AI tends to isolate us. It doesn't teach us social skills. But mental health is very social: individuals don't live in a vacuum; they need to connect with others."

Media requests

Université de Montréal
Phone: 514-343-6111, ext. 67960